ROCH 2006: She left me again! Oh noes!
Lu Wushuang: the actress who played her was ok, could have been better. In the book, I always felt that she and Yang Guo could have been a nicely matched couple. Both have sharp wits and sharp tongues, can be playful, but have hair trigger tempers and can hold a grudge. Too bad they cut much of their interaction. And I missed the ox! They had Yang Guo do all his LWS rescuing on foot. And there wasn't as much with the Beggar Clan.
Cheng Ying: wore a freaky "human-skin mask" through most of this. When we finally see her face, she looks all right. I suppose they must cast this show with Little Dragon Girl as the most beautiful, then Guo Fu and Huang Rong. At any rate, Cheng Ying, unlike her cousin, is much more of a traditional demure maiden with some martial arts skills.
Yelu Qi, Wanyan Ping et all: Decently acted. This little subplot has Wanyan Ping seeking revenge for her family's death on Yelu Qi's father, but unable to, and Yelu Qi's father explaining how his actions were in turn vengeance for Wanyan Ping's family's slaughtering of /his/ family back in the day... at the end of it, she can't kill Yelu Qi after all, and maybe that feud can end. It's something for Yang Guo to reflect upon...
Li Mochou: There she is again! The actress needs to work on her evil laugh. It wasn't terribly convincing. It's almost as irritating as Yang Guo's silly laugh. Gah!
Hua Shan (the mountain), Hong Qi Gong, and Ouyang Feng. Damn, they cut out almost all of this section. I was looking forward to seeing HQG's centipede feast. No sign of the bandits known as the Five Tibetan Clowns (though they were mentioned in passing later.) Ok. Now this is going overboard. Hong Qi Gong can TELEPATHICALLY (through some manipulation of his inner energy, I suppose) transmit the Dog-beating Stick methods to Yang Guo? That was just silly. At any rate, here we have the end of another old feud... I found it very touching in the anime version, but here it left me a bit flat.
The horse! They cut all the cool parts from the scenes on Huashan, but elaborated for many minutes of screen time on Yang Guo and the horse? Sheesh. It was the Yang Guo/Little Dragon Girl loooove goop all over again.
Hero's Meet: Aha, here we are with Guo Jing, Huang Rong, Guo Fu, and the rest. Guo Jing finally finds out that Yang Guo hasn't been safely stashed away with the Quanzhen (Taoist) sect all this time. Yang Guo hangs out with the other kids for awhile. Then here's the meeting and the Golden Wheel monk (they all seem to have turned into Mongols in this version) and the big fights. They cut out one of the combats in the contest, too bad. Yang Guo has a magic nose! Apparently, just /seeing/ Little Dragon Girl isn't good enough. Here, he sniff sniff sniffs...while the LDG Enya-esque leitmotif starts playing. Please. Just. Stop.
Guo Jing: I liked the actor, but I felt they should have cast someone bigger, with more of a physical presence. I always pictured him as something of a brute, with his 18 Dragon Subduing Palms. Here he almost looks smaller than Yang Guo.
Huang Rong: What's with the unnaturally wide eyes? It looks distractingly strange. Other than that, I liked her. She is supposed to be clever, seeing what GJ can't, and using words to separate YG and LDG. Which this actress pulls off pretty well.
Guo Fu: GJ and HR's spoiled daughter. Pretty actress. Sympathetic so far.
Wu brothers: Guo Fu's foster brothers (in effect, though technically, they're just Guo Jing's students.) About what they were supposed to be, that is, chasing after Guo Fu, not too clever, with middling skills in martial arts, and generally resentful and contemptuous of Yang Guo.
Huo Dou: the Mongolian prince. I liked the actor they cast here. He plays him as an arrogant princeling, slightly effete (after all, he does use that fan as his main weapon!), quick to take advantage and not terribly honorable.
Golden Wheel Monk: the strongest of the "enemy" here. Powerful inner energy (demonstrated via CGI, but relatively tasteful CGI). Looks good. Telekinetically controlled wheels o' death! Had some decent fight scenes between him and Little Dragon Girl (what happened to the golden bell/sphere thingies on her white sash o'doom?) and Yang Guo. Speaking of telekinesis, I'll try to erase from my mind that earlier parasol fight (Parasol fight!) between Little Dragon Girl and Li Mochou.
Fight scenes...apparently no one ever moves their feet or legs anymore to move around in a fight. That's so passe. Instead, they slide around magically, or simply fly like Superman. (In the old days, when people jumped off roofs and they just ran the film backwards, at least we some idea that they had to use their own muscles.) Oh yes, and in keeping with genre tradition, no one ever bleeds or even gets bruised. They show their injury by spraying blood from their mouths. Originally, this happened when the characters had internal injuries, but now, it's universal. But they didn't do the Jedi mind tricks from the 9 Yin Manual...awww...too bad. It would have been funny to watch the big monk (Da Er Ba) copying Yang Guo and tricked into whacking himself in the face.
Fight scenes...now they're telekinetically tossing huge boulders around! I suppose the mystically confusing rock formation business was never going to be convincing, but this... Ha, it does look cool. Nice effects. Big rocks whizzing around at the enemy. But...still stupid.
Yang Guo and Little Dragon Girl openly declare their love for each other: Shock! Horror! The shame! The crowd is squicked by the master-student couple. It's like incest. Theoretically. But in the story, she's only about 4 years older, and she looks about the same age. Well, every romantic couple needs some obstacles. They walk out and plan to live quietly in the Ancient Tomb forever, avoiding the censure of society. Of course, this is not to be.
"Gu-gu!"
"Guo-er!"
"Gu-gu!"
"Guo-er!"
